| Magikarp 72/123 HGSS Uncommon MINT! Pokémon | $2.58 USD | raw | - | - | 4/6/2026 |
| MAGIKARP 72/123 COMMON HEARTGOLD & SOULSILVER POKEMON LP | $0.71 USD | raw | - | - | 4/6/2026 |
| Magikarp Common Normal HeartGold SoulSilver 72/123 HP Pokémon TCG | $2.19 USD | raw | - | - | 4/5/2026 |
| Magikarp - 72/123 HeartGold & SoulSilver - Pokémon TCG | $2.84 USD | raw | - | - | 4/4/2026 |
| Magikarp Common HeartGold SoulSilver 72/123 LP | $1.99 USD | raw | - | - | 4/4/2026 |
| Magikarp 72/123 Common HeartGold & SoulSilver LP Pokemon Card | $1.99 USD | raw | - | - | 4/4/2026 |
| Magikarp #72/123 Heartgold Soulsilver Pokemon TCG MP | $1.85 USD | raw | - | - | 4/3/2026 |
| Magikarp 72/123 Common HeartGold & SoulSilver Pokemon LP | $4.88 USD | raw | - | - | 3/29/2026 |
| Magikarp 72/123 Common HeartGold SoulSilver Heavily Played Pokémon Card | $2.49 USD | raw | - | - | 3/29/2026 |
| Magikarp #72/123 Heartgold Soulsilver Pokemon TCG (x4) - Common - Set Of 4 🔥💎 | $0.99 USD | raw | - | - | 3/29/2026 |
| Magikarp Common HeartGold SoulSilver 72/123 NM | $2.25 USD | raw | - | - | 3/28/2026 |
| Pokemon TCG Magikarp 72/123 HeartGold SoulSilver LP | $2.24 USD | raw | - | - | 3/28/2026 |
| Pokémon Magikarp 72/123 HS HeartGold & SoulSilver LP | $2.00 USD | raw | - | - | 3/26/2026 |
| Magikarp HeartGold SoulSilver 72/123 LP-NM Pokemon card | $2.15 USD | raw | - | - | 3/23/2026 |
| Magikarp 72/123 Heartgold & Soulsilver Reverse Holo | $11.00 USD | raw | - | - | 3/22/2026 |
| Magikarp 72/123 Common HeartGold SoulSilver NM - LP Pokemon TCG | $4.87 USD | raw | - | - | 3/19/2026 |
| Pokemon - Magikarp 72/123 Common Heart Gold Soul Silver: Base Set | $5.22 USD | raw | - | - | 3/17/2026 |
| Magikarp 72/123 - Heart Gold Soul Silver - Pokemon Card | $1.50 USD | raw | - | - | 3/17/2026 |
| Pokemon Magikarp 72/123 REVERSE HOLO Vintage 2010 | $12.11 USD | raw | - | - | 3/16/2026 |
| Magikarp Common HeartGold SoulSilver 72/123 NM 121 | $2.99 USD | raw | - | - | 3/16/2026 |